In this week’s In-Ear Insights, Katie and Chris discuss a recent consumer data experience with one vendor sharing data to another vendor without the consumer’s active consent. In this show, you’ll learn what active consent is (and why it matters), how to track down the likely vectors of data sharing, and how marketers should think about consumer data collection and sharing.
Subscribe To This Show!
If you're not already subscribed to In-Ear Insights, get set up now!
- In-Ear Insights on Apple Podcasts
- In-Ear Insights on Google Podcasts
- In-Ear Insights on all other podcasting software
Advertisement: Google Search Console for Marketers
Of the many tools in the Google Marketing Platform, none is more overlooked than Google Search Console. Marketers assume it’s just for SEO, but the information contained within benefits search, social media, public relations, advertising, and so much more. In our new Google Search Console for Marketers course, you’ll learn what Google Search Console is, why it matters to all marketers, and then dig deep into each of the features of the platform.
When you’re done, you’ll have working knowledge of the entire platform and what it can do – and you’ll be ready to start making the most of this valuable marketing tool.
Sponsor This Show!Are you struggling to reach the right audiences? Trust Insights offers sponsorships in our newsletters, podcasts, and media properties to help your brand be seen and heard by the right people. Our media properties reach almost 100,000 people every week, from the In Ear Insights podcast to the Almost Timely and In the Headlights newsletters. Reach out to us today to learn more.
Watch the video here:
Can’t see anything? Watch it on YouTube here.
Listen to the audio here:
- Need help with your company’s data and analytics? Let us know!
- Join our free Slack group for marketers interested in analytics!
What follows is an AI-generated transcript. The transcript may contain errors and is not a substitute for listening to the episode.
Christopher Penn 0:02
This is In-Ear Insights the Trust Insights podcast. Do you want to use AI in your marketing but you’re not sure where to start? Take a class with Trust Insights and the marketing AI Institute. The AI Academy offers more than 25 classes and certification courses to start you on your AI journey including our intelligent attribution modeling for marketers certification. One membership gets you access to all 25 classes. Visit Trust insights.ai slash AI Academy to learn more and enroll today. That’s Trust insights.ai slash AI Academy to enroll today. Are you struggling to reach the right audiences? Trust Insights offers sponsorships in our newsletters, podcasts and media properties to help your brand be seen and heard by the right people. Our media properties with almost 100,000 people every week from the In-Ear Insights podcast to the most timely and in the headlights newsletters. Reach out to us today at Trust insights.ai slash contact to learn more. Again, that’s Trust insights.ai slash contact. In this week’s in your insights. Let’s talk about data forensics, both from the consumer perspective and from the marketers perspective. So Katie, you’ve got a bit of a mystery for us data detectives to solve.
Katie Robbert 1:15
I do. And it was one of those things as a consumer that took me aback a little bit. So even though you know we run a data science company, there’s still a lot about how data is shared, that we don’t necessarily have the answer for so something that we want to start to pick apart is so over the weekend, on Saturday, I went to Walgreens a local pharmacy chain to pick up a haircare product, not a product I’d ever used not a product that I ever talked about. Not a product I’d ever even known existed until I got to the store and saw Oh, this looks like the kind of thing I’m looking for. But I didn’t go into the store thinking I want this exact product. I’ve done some research on it. So there’s a little bit of that happening. So I bought the product. I came home and then on Sunday, I start seeing ads for it on Instagram. Now my first thought is, how the heck does Instagram know that just 24 hours prior I for the first time discovered and purchase this product. Now I don’t have a smart system set up on my phone. So I haven’t been talking about it, there is a good chance that my phone is still listening regardless. But then I would have had to have named that exact thing in the course of conversation with myself because my husband was working all weekend. So it to me, it’s just sort of a mystery as to how Instagram, within 24 hours knew that I was in possession of this product. So Chris, what are you thinking?
Christopher Penn 2:51
Well, let’s ask some questions. So the ad on Instagram was by Walgreens was it by the hair company?
Katie Robbert 2:57
It was by the hair company.
Christopher Penn 2:59
Okay. And when you were at the shelf, did you notice it was a standard Walgreens shelf? Was there an electronic display? Was it an endcap? What was it?
Katie Robbert 3:10
It was your standard? Metal cold shelf?
Christopher Penn 3:15
There was no cool display. Okay. And what apps were you running on your phone at the time, you might not know that. But if there are apps in the background that were running,
Katie Robbert 3:28
um, I don’t know what was running in the background. At the time, I was listening to an audio book, I was listening to overdrive through my library. But I highly doubt that my library is transmitting haircare product data. Most likely things like you know, GPS and that kind of thing. But otherwise, none that no apps that I’m aware of. And that may create a problem.
Christopher Penn 3:53
And did you use your Walgreens customer card?
Katie Robbert 3:57
I did. And that was my thought. Yep.
Christopher Penn 4:00
Okay, so there’s three, maybe four different possibilities here. One, apps, particularly Spotify can transmit location based data within stores back to merchants and vendors. They are very, very good at that their location data from a source that we have talked to can target you down to the aisle so it knows he can know what aisle you’re in. And obviously, based on that what kinds of stuff is in that aisle? That’s one possibility. second possibility would be beacons, which are the NFC devices that a merchant would typically place in and around a store that track your movement either throughout the store or very specific aisles. So if there was a special cool display is a nonzero chance there’s a beacon embedded within that display. You’ll see this in electronic pricing shelves like if you go on to like Alibaba for example. You can actually as a merchant by shells have cameras and displays built right Along with facial recognition, and you can tie that to, you know, different merchants. And so the shelf can recognize you, and display and change the pricing for you, like give you a discount, or a promotion. But based on what you’re saying, it sounds like the most logical thing is the Walgreens customer file. Obviously, you know, every merchant with these loyalty cards, shares that data, well sells that data to other to other brands. And if you’re seeing ads for it, what work, what I’m wondering is, if it’s just the, you know, in the file, it’s like, Hey, you bought this thing, or you just bought something from this company. Because normally, when you get an ad for something you already bought, it’s usually because a marketer didn’t set up their advertising system correctly, and is trying to sell you something you just bought, which is kind of a waste of ad dollars.
Katie Robbert 5:54
Well, and so that was the other thing I was thinking is I’ve already purchased the thing, why am I now seeing ads for it? Which so that’s a whole other conversation about how improperly ads can be set up in the wrong messaging, depending on where they are on the customer journey. You know, so to your first point about the location data, through apps, like Spotify, you know, that actually makes a lot of sense, because I have previously seen ads for things that I was looking at or considering at other kinds of stores. While when I was at Walgreens, I happened to be in the haircare aisle, they had no fit no like fancy displays, and it’s actually a much older Walgreens. And so I would have, I would have been less surprised if I just seen general haircare ads, because it’s a rather long aisle. And there’s hundreds of different kinds of products, but they were able to show me an ad specifically for the product that I purchased, which is what sort of, for me raised my hackles of like, okay, someone sold my data. And within 24 hours, I started seeing ads for the thing. So I’m guessing, Chris, that your analysis but the Walgreens Customer Care number is the thing that tied me to this specific ad, what I was even more caught off guard by was the quickness in which it happened. It wasn’t a week later, it was literally within 24 hours for this exact product.
Christopher Penn 7:26
The thing about the 24 hour delay tells me that it’s likely the Walgreens customer number because Spotify and other GPS based apps, that date is near real time. So you could have been seeing, you know, Instagram as fat as soon as that evening. If if they was because what they’re going to try and do, ideally is hard you before you leave the store, like if you’re listening to something on on the on the radio, you’re hearing that in the in the non paid version would be a good way to try and save that shopping cart. If it’s a day later, that suggests batch processing, like you get a daily file from the vendor. And then you know, they load that into their ad systems and they spin up, it goes into the next day as batch. And to your point, if it had been a week later, that’s something different. That’s either the vendor gets a much less frequent data files, or they are just really bad at running their own Mar tech stack. But that 24 hour delay tells me it’s probably a daily batch process. And then that gets loaded. And so from a forensics perspective, the the thing that you would do next to test it is no, I’m not saying go out and buy a whole bunch of stuff at Walgreens. But go and you know, browse Walgreens without buying something one visit and see if you see any new ads in the Instagram feed, if so that tells you that it’s not the customer data file itself, and then maybe do go buy a sample of sub products that you know, could likely be running e commerce ads, and see if again, those start to show up in your Instagram feed as well. And that that will give you that sort of scientific test like yeah, there’s, there’s some causality here for this. There’s not for these other things.
Katie Robbert 9:05
So you know, it’s interesting. If we go back to Spotify for a second, I knew that they had the you know, you can break it down into very small geographic regions. And they know when their customers are either driving or traveling through certain areas. So I’ve experienced that before. And I’ve actually set up ads to that effect before. And that makes sense because it’s using your GPS information to say you are in the town of Framingham, Massachusetts, therefore the you know, vendor who is purchased ad space in the town of Framingham is now going to have you listened to these very specific ads. That to me makes a lot of sense. It was the for it. A bit of a disconnect between having no awareness of the product and then seeing starting to see ads on the product. You know, I wonder if this is something that consumers are even aware about? Done with their information. As they’re signing up for these, you know, discount cards, I think that there’s this lack of understanding that these discount cards are actually a bigger deal to the companies that are issuing them. So you might get like, a $1 off or a $2 off coupon. But the company is getting much, much more in terms of rich customer behavioral data, in order to develop new products and show ads and do e commerce and you know, basically follow you everywhere.
Christopher Penn 10:36
Katie Robbert 13:00
Christopher Penn 14:11
Katie Robbert 17:17
You know, you bring up this notion of the active consent. And I feel like we’ve talked about this before, probably on a different podcast. Um, you know, but I can absolutely see why companies would want to do the bare minimum and sort of like skirt around this notion of active consent, because it’s not in their best interest, to not have complete access to consumer data. So if they are putting privacy policies and consent forms and tutorials in the face of their consumer, the likelihood of them getting the data starts to go down considerably. Because a lot of people are saying, Well, no, I don’t want to share my data with you at all, ever. I want nothing to do with discounts, I want nothing to do with you, knowing who I am, my purchasing patterns, my likes my dislikes, I want nothing to do with that. So you get nothing. And then that then puts the companies at a severe handicap. And as I’m saying this, I realized, we have had this conversation before on a different podcast. That said, it’s still such an important topic that it definitely bears repeating. Because as it gets increasingly more difficult for companies to get consumer data, they have to then think of other ways to reach their key demographic and their market. And you’re gonna start to see the companies that are less creative, less agile, less innovative, just start to fall by the wayside when it comes to digital marketing.
Christopher Penn 18:47
Yep, and the other thing is, as awareness properly, properly, becomes greater about the misuse of data, things like AI and you know, creating unintended biases, there’s an additional disincentive for you to tell a company who you are, what your preferences are, because you can obviously infer things like race and religion from those those data points. So yeah, there’s a strong disincentive to want to share that data, which means that as marketers, we have to figure out okay, what is the strong enough incentive to get somebody to want to share that data? If we agree that data is valuable, which I think if you’re listening to this podcast, you probably agree with that. Then what are we willing to pay for? What are we willing to give for it? What’s in it for the customer, and in a lot of cases, there’s not enough, there’s not enough in it for the customer to go, Okay, I think this is worth forking over my data, and potentially even being exposed to a hostile algorithm down the road, depending on the company. So the takeaway here for the marketer is you’ve got to decide what customer data is worth, and then be willing to pay it and be willing to pay a premium for it because as legislation continues as privacy groups get better as consumers get better at understanding how their data isn’t, is not being misused, you will be in competition with your competitors, not only for the sale, but also for the right to the data. And you would better be able to outsell your competitors on the value of what you’re going to give them in exchange for this data. Because it’s, you know, to cater to your point, it’s a sale, it’s just like, buying the product itself, that giving that data over is a sale. And we as marketers have to convince people to sell us their data.
Katie Robbert 20:31
Mm hmm. I agree. And, you know, as you know, being on both sides of it is really interesting as a consumer, in some ways, I almost felt completely violated of how dare you know, the thing that I just bought, and then show me ads for it. But I was the marketer, I’m like, Oh, this is great. I have access to consumer data. And so it is definitely that like, push pull of, I don’t know which side is the right side. So there has to be that middle ground of the consumer actively knowing and the market are actively telling.
Christopher Penn 21:04
Yep. As with so many things in life, consensus, everything gets somebody say yes, and you’re all good to go. If you got follow up questions about this or any other topic, pop on over to our slack group over at Trust insights.ai slash analytics for marketers, where you can talk with over 1300 other marketers about topics like this or anything else under the sun that’s related to marketing analytics. And if you haven’t already subscribed to this show, please do so go to Trust insights.ai slash ti podcast or just subscribe on whatever platform it is listening on. Thanks for listening and we’ll talk to you soon. want help solving your company’s data analytics and digital marketing problems. This is Trust insights.ai today and let us know how we can help you
Need help with your marketing data and analytics?
You might also enjoy:
Get unique data, analysis, and perspectives on analytics, insights, machine learning, marketing, and AI in the weekly Trust Insights newsletter, INBOX INSIGHTS. Subscribe now for free; new issues every Wednesday!
Want to learn more about data, analytics, and insights? Subscribe to In-Ear Insights, the Trust Insights podcast, with new 10-minute or less episodes every week.