sowhatmartechsprawl

So What? Taming MarTech Sprawl

So What? Marketing Analytics and Insights Live

airs every Thursday at 1 pm EST.

You can watch on YouTube Live. Be sure to subscribe and follow so you never miss an episode!

In this episode, Katie Robbert and John Wall share practical strategies for taming your tech stack and cutting wasted software spend.

You will discover how hidden fees, forgotten trials, and disconnected tools fuel Martech Sprawl across your entire company. Using a simple AI prompt with your expense records, you will uncover duplicate subscriptions and upcoming renewals before they drain your budget. This approach empowers you to spot overlooked features in the platforms you already own, letting you trim your Martech Sprawl without disrupting daily work. Applying a clear decision framework alongside practical tests will help you assign tool ownership and build lasting cost control.

Watch the video here:

Can’t see anything? Watch it on YouTube here.

In this episode you’ll learn:

  • What martech sprawl is
  • Why AI makes the problem worse, not better
  • How to start taming martech sprawl

Transcript:

What follows is an AI-generated transcript. The transcript may contain errors and is not a substitute for listening to the episode.

Katie Robbert – 00:00
Well, hey everyone. Happy Thursday. Welcome to So What? The Marketing Analytics and Insights Live Show. It is just me and John today. Hey, John.
John Wall – 00:30
Hey. Christopher Penn-free today.
Katie Robbert – 00:32
Christopher—we don’t know. Chris is off in Texas somewhere. We just kind of dropped him off, and he’s going to find his way home. We don’t know what’s going to happen today because I am left in charge of the buttons, and we all know that’s never a good idea. Today John and I are talking about taming the MarTech sprawl. We’re going to go over what MarTech sprawl is, why AI makes the problem worse, not better, and how to start taming it. John, when I say MarTech sprawl, what do you think of?
John Wall – 01:07
Yeah, it’s funny. When we talked about doing this as a topic and it came up, I started thinking about it. It used to be about five years ago or so, or even 10 years ago, there were a bunch of different options as far as email service provider and CRM and all these things that marketing touched. You would have to take a long time and figure out, “All right, how many things are we buying, and how do they all work together?” It gets exponentially more complicated. Every time you add another tool, you’re asking, “Okay, which ones does it plug into? By plugging these things in, are we going to have to start paying all these API fees?” It’s going to be crazy expensive.
John Wall – 01:42
We’ve come to the point now where I think MarTech sprawl isn’t even correct. It’s more SaaS sprawl, or you could even say software sprawl, because you even have to deal with your accounting system. Now we have all these AI tools too that feed into the mix, and it’s all cross-department. It’s not all just pure marketing anymore. We have the official MarTech Scott Brinker eye chart showing 50 billion types of marketing software that are now available for everybody here. Even Scott himself says, “This is only the stuff that is a brand, where you actually go buy the thing. This is not counting half a million WordPress plugins that you can pay for and buy that are on the marketplace.”
John Wall – 02:32
This is just the tip of the iceberg.
Katie Robbert – 02:35
And this that I’m sharing directly from their website—I don’t even think there’s a version where I can zoom in and actually see what’s on this page. It really is this tiny. I remember when we started looking at this. I’m a little bit later to the marketing industry than you and Chris are, so I don’t know honestly how long this has been around, and you can certainly keep me honest. I remember the first time I saw this, it wasn’t necessarily broken out into these categories, which I honestly can’t—well, yeah, that’s what happens when you zoom in. That’s a terrible idea.
John Wall – 03:12
Oh, they’re using the thumbnails, just the website—a tiny 30-pixel image. That’s all they can squeeze in.
Katie Robbert – 03:18
That’s all they can squeeze in. You have advertising and promotion, content experience, social and relationships, and then there’s subcategories—oops. Commerce and sales, data and management, and then go down from there. This is ridiculous. When I first saw this, maybe in 2018 or 2019, it was readable. It was something that you could actually wrap your head around and say, “Okay, this looks like these are all the players.” Now—and I don’t know how to zoom back out again—this is ridiculous.
John Wall – 04:02
Yeah, it’s come to the point where it’s completely niched down. For whatever weird little business segment you’re in—if you’re doing accounting for bowling alleys—there’s a specific piece of software that takes into account how bowlers’ lives work and all that stuff. It’s completely unmanageable.
Katie Robbert – 04:23
Well, I remember a couple of years ago when generative AI came out, the growth of the map was plus 4,000 new AI tools. Then the next year it was plus 11,000 new AI tools. I feel like that’s just continued to make that map unusable. It’s kind of ridiculous. You said what’s not on here is WordPress and those other plugins. These are, for lack of a better term, the shell software—you buy Salesforce, but there’s all the different little bits and pieces and bits and bobs that you can add on, or connectors, that contribute to that MarTech sprawl.
Katie Robbert – 05:19
The other thing that’s not on here—and this is a bigger issue—are things that people are vibe-coding themselves and adding into their tech stack. When we think about the tech stack, we think about all of the different pieces of software and all of the different tools that we’re using to do our day-to-day work inside and out. Most of us can probably count off, “Well, I use my CRM and I use a word processor and I use this and I use that.” We know the things we use that are visible. What we don’t know is what’s invisible to us behind the scenes powering a lot of these things. That’s where a lot of these homegrown vibe-coding tools start to come in.
Katie Robbert – 06:07
Ted from X has a question: “So do businesses just start defaulting to the easiest integrated solutions?” A lot of them do that. I was talking with someone in the financial sector a couple of weeks ago, and she said that they have a lot of legacy systems, and all of the different legacy systems don’t talk to each other, and there are issues with each one of them. She probably had about a dozen of them that they do business with, and they had been scoping out and looking at vendors that kind of did everything. Before she decided to sign anything, she was asking, “Wait a second, is this introducing more problems, or am I just buying something that looks like on the surface it’s going to solve problems?”
Katie Robbert – 06:52
To answer your question, Ted, yeah, a lot of businesses default to—what I’m going to put in quotations—what appears to be the easiest integrated solution. One of the challenges with all of these different tools is actually the integration. If you look again at this giant, massive map, what’s not on here is how they all talk to each other. That’s where a lot of companies are struggling. As their MarTech stack sprawls, they become less and less connected between all of these different data points, which is why a lot of them are trying to vibe-code these integration systems or tools. That then just continues to contribute to the sprawl.
John Wall – 07:35
Right? Because anything that gets built like that means there’s somebody in the org that has to babysit that and make sure when it breaks that you’re not stopping all flights nationwide for two days. That’s how this stuff happens and where it goes. Most of the time this is a great argument for having a network, like our Slack group, where you can talk to people and just say, “Hey, I’ve got X, Y, and Z and I’m plugging this in. I’m looking at this—how did that go for you?” Most of the time, there’s no substitute for the fact that you just have to buy it, turn it on, and then see what actually works or doesn’t work.
John Wall – 08:11
It’s pretty rare that there’s something where it’s got 50,000 five-star reviews and everybody is raving about how it was totally zero effort to get turned on and attached. That can happen. But the learning curve is pretty abusive here for a lot of this stuff.
Katie Robbert – 08:32
We did ask in our Slack community, Analytics for Marketers, what people are doing about their sprawl. You can join for free at TrustInsights.ai/analyticsformarketers. Today’s question of the day was: “Are you experiencing MarTech sprawl? How many tools have you added to your stack this year?” Some people are saying, “We haven’t added any.” They’re on a cost-cutting spree, which is where a lot of companies are right now, because these things add up. Very few tools are free and useful. Some are saying that they’re paying for a few that they used on a free plan, and then that free plan, when you’re not looking, switches over to a paid plan because in order to get the free demo, you actually have to put in a credit card.
Katie Robbert – 09:20
They say, “Don’t worry, you can cancel before anything is charged.” Somehow you get into a time vortex and those 30 days go by in the blink of an eye, and you say, “Oh, my gosh, I’m on day 31 now. I’m committed for a whole month. I might as well use it.” Then it becomes this vicious cycle of you never actually canceling it.
John Wall – 09:40
Yeah, that stuff collects. Unfortunately, we’re at a position where nobody’s really looking at new tools because expenses have shot up for everyone. There’s stuff that’s getting on the chopping block. People are starting to look at, “Well, what can I rip out of here to save myself a monthly fee?” Because those monthly fees stay for eternity. You’re tuning your profitability if you can throw those overboard.
Katie Robbert – 10:01
Let me ask you this question, John. You’ve sat through probably a lot of vendor demos of new tools, because that’s something that I know in previous lives of jobs you had to do, and you’ve done it a few times for us at Trust Insights. What are some of the red flags that you tend to listen for when vendors say, “Oh, I can solve all of your problems. This is the most integrated solution you’re ever going to find. We totally connect with all of your tools”? What are some of the things you listen for when you’re going through a vendor demo?
John Wall – 10:42
The big one is you can’t trust the demo. You can never trust the demo. It’s, “Let me talk to some other customers.” Salesforce was the champion of this, saying, “Hey, we’re going to do our annual conference and we’re going to invite all our prospects.” The customers come to learn what’s the latest and greatest thing, and the prospects can be in there and talk to actual customers and say, “Hey, I heard you plugged in X to Y. How did that go? How did that work?” You have proof points for all that.
John Wall – 11:14
The only other gotcha to keep in mind—and this does still happen, though it’s not as bad as it used to be—is when you integrate things, you have to pay attention to whether it is metered, because you’re going to be initiating a lot more traffic between multiple systems. Whether it’s an API charge—there’s some email systems that every time they go talk to Salesforce to do something, the cash register rings. You don’t realize that if you’re on the 1,000-hits-a-month program, and now suddenly you install a marketing system that hits it 250,000 times a month, you don’t want to be getting that $20,000 invoice. That’s just a backbreaker for your programs. Talk to other people, prove the integrations work, and prove that you don’t have to buy seats or API tokens to make it work.
John Wall – 12:05
You kind of need to get into it. Another big one that you can push in a demo is ask specific questions about integrations, because people will just say, “Oh, this is integrated.” Well, in a lot of systems, an integration could just mean it looks over there and sees what the data is. It doesn’t mean that it can write data over there, and it doesn’t mean that it can write data to your system. People refer to a full two-way integration as the same thing as just a read-only, one-way thing. Those are two entirely different things, and it may or may not solve what problem you’re trying to fix.
Katie Robbert – 12:40
One of the things we’re seeing now—let me share my screen. This is my Claude instance. Inside Claude, you have what’s called connectors. This is Claude’s version of solving some of that integration issue between different systems. You have to be paying for Claude. It’s another tool in your stack. To your point, depending on how you are accessing the data from the systems it’s connecting to, you could be burning up tokens. Tokens are kind of this mythical, made-up thing that people have worked to calculate. You can say it costs 6,000 tokens for five Schrute Bucks to six Stanley Nickels, if you get that reference.
Katie Robbert – 13:33
At the end of the day, what it means is if you use it too much, you’re going to get a bigger bill because you have a certain set number of tokens every single month or every single week. Adding more connectors to solve your integration issues between your systems means you’re going to be burning more tokens and spending more money with Claude versus a different system. Or to your point, John, every time you pull the data out of a system, it might say, “Hey, you’re accessing our APIs. This is going to cost you.” It’s things that you need to be aware of. It’s not just having more tools; it’s how much money you’re spending to get the data from tool to tool.
John Wall – 14:11
Yeah, it’s crazy, isn’t it? That was kind of a trick a lot of people noticed: if Claude is behaving like a user, you’re actually skipping the API. It can pretend it’s you and go get this data. That might work, but of course then you have to think about, “Well, now I’m burning all these tokens. Which is cheaper, the API access or tokens?” You might not actually be saving any money, and maybe making it worse for yourself.
Katie Robbert – 14:36
Then the question is, how do we solve this? What do we do about it? If you subscribe to Inbox Insights—which is our weekly newsletter at TrustInsights.ai/newsletter—Chris wrote about this this week. Inside the newsletter, he actually shared a prompt that you can use with AI to start with to say, “Hey, I need to take a look at my MarTech sprawl.” I did this exercise for Trust Insights, and it actually helped me understand a lot of what we’re paying for. This is a synthetic version, so this is not our data or anyone’s data. This is completely made up.
Katie Robbert – 15:18
To give the example, what you basically want to do is take a look at your credit card statement or your vendor list in QuickBooks—or whatever accounting system you’re using—and take a look at the transactions for the past year. That’s the data that you’re going to want to look at in order to do this exercise. In the newsletter this week, Inbox Insights, Chris actually outlines the prompt. This is the prompt structure that he put in the newsletter: “We are Bramblewood Consulting [Synthetic], and we do B2B marketing strategy and training for mid-sized companies. I work in marketing, and we do a monthly newsletter, a podcast, webinars, website content, and CRM-based sales follow-up.” What the prompt is doing is listing the things that your company does.
Katie Robbert – 16:08
When the AI system takes a look at all of the different vendors that you’re paying for, it says, “Oh, you have Ahrefs—that’s an SEO tool. You said you do SEO. You’re using StreamYard—that’s a video broadcasting tool, and you said you do podcasts and webinars and video. You’re paying for Salesforce—that’s a CRM, and you said you do CRM work.” The prompt structure is meant to give you the starting point to match up the work that you do so that the AI has a point of reference to say why you’re paying for this tool in the first place. “I’m a small business and I do everything from… I’m a Google shop,” or “I’m a Microsoft shop.”
Katie Robbert – 16:48
If I’m paying for Microsoft Office, but I said I’m a Google shop, it’s going to flag, “Well, why are you paying for this and not that? Our biggest marketing challenge is efficiency and knowing what tools we have. We currently pay for the following software solutions.” This is where you then take the data that you exported either from your credit card statement or your accounting list and include it as the data set. I ran this through, and in this example, this is what it found: this particular company, Bramblewood Consulting, was paying for 29 tools totaling over $30,000 in 12 months. That’s a lot of money. That’s a lot of software to be paying for.
Katie Robbert – 17:32
What we found was that there were six clear cuts worth roughly $2,000 a year, which is not insignificant, especially as you try to continue to find those efficiencies over time. There are three overlaps to check, worth almost $3,000 a year. There’s about four renewals coming up in the next 45 days worth about $3,000—so do we want to renew those? And then payment processing fees, which is almost $8,000, which is more than any single tool. That’s something that we’re also looking at for Trust Insights is how we’re processing payments, because those are the hidden fees where you think, “Well, my QuickBooks subscription isn’t that much.” When you dig into actually how they’re processing, it could be something like this.
Katie Robbert – 18:19
When you start to look at the tools that you’re using, one of the traps that people are falling into—and this goes back to the demo question, John—is a lot of tools are now adding on new AI capabilities where if you just pay a little bit more, they can unlock that for you. I know that some SEO tools are doing AI visibility. I know that some CRM systems are doing record supplementation. These are the little gotchas that actually start to sprawl your tech stack and end up costing you more money. I haven’t talked to a single client who isn’t taking a critical eye to their tech stack, especially this year, to say, “What am I paying for? What am I using?” Because it sneaks up on you really quickly.
John Wall – 19:08
Yeah. Looking at those numbers there, think about this: you just did a rough run and you realize, “Well, only two-thirds of this we know is absolutely legit.” We’re questioning a full third of what’s going on here and need to look into it.
Katie Robbert – 19:22
Again, synthetic example—these may not be true numbers. This is just the example. The next thing the prompt does: first the prompt will say, “Here’s what I found. Here’s all the different things. This is your high-level executive summary.” Then it goes into what we actually pay for, and it breaks it down by category. In sales, marketing, and operations, we’re paying about $21,000 for the following tools: HubSpot, Google Workspace, Zoom, Semrush, Slack, Asana, QuickBooks, Mailchimp, Monday, and Calendly. I look at this and I say, “Well, why do you have Asana and Monday? Those are both project management tools.” The rest seems fine. If you’re on Google Workspace, then you have Google Calendars.
Katie Robbert – 20:09
Do you also need Calendly, or can you start to build in those meeting invites? Calendly is basically just a calendar scheduling tool, and if you’re using Google Workspace, that’s now built into the calendar feature so that you can build those links. That was my first takeaway from that. Then you have your website and hosting, which is about $4,600. You have your Kinsta, WordPress hosting, AWS, GoDaddy, Squarespace, and Cloudflare. That’s not a world I’m as familiar with, but does anything stick out to you, John, as duplicates?
John Wall – 20:49
Well, the good news is it’s not a ton of money, just overall. That’s pretty much straight. The only issue with that is GoDaddy and Squarespace—those tend to both be domain sites, so that should be rolled under the same vendor. Having two vendors there doesn’t make any sense. After that, the other ones are solid because you’ve got hosting. AWS is probably email services or generic stuff, though you should look at that one to see what exactly it is, because that’s just raw storage—that doesn’t mean anything. Cloudflare is a given. You’ve got to have some vendor—that’s a security front end keeping the denial-of-service attacks away from you. That’s pretty tight, though the GoDaddy-Squarespace overlap would definitely be something to dig into.
Katie Robbert – 21:34
Next—and this is where I think a lot of companies are falling right now that they really need to take a critical eye to—I was surprised that I was concerned that our AI subscriptions were going to be much more scattered and higher, but we’ve actually done a really good job of condensing down what we’re using. In this synthetic example, this company is paying for five different AI services: ChatGPT, Claude, Jasper—which the last login was in March, yet they’re still getting billed for it—Perplexity Pro, and Google One AI Premium. The question there that we had to first ask ourselves, and then we ask our clients who run into this, is what is the purpose of each?
Katie Robbert – 22:19
When generative AI first started rolling out a few years ago, there were significant differences between the systems and what they were capable of. That’s not really the case anymore. What you can do in one, you can credibly do in another. You’re never going to get one-to-one parity between ChatGPT, Claude, and Google Gemini, but it really gives you the opportunity to look critically at why you’re using AI and what your use cases are. Can you condense it down? Because now in today’s AI world, skills are fairly transferable. Agentic AI is really just making sure that you have a really good standard operating procedure that should exist outside of your AI system. You shouldn’t really be using AI to make your decisions for you—that’s critical thinking that you, the human, should have.
Katie Robbert – 23:15
That would be a red flag for me, that this particular company is paying for five different AI systems when they probably only need one, maybe two, depending on how they’re set up and how they’re using it.
John Wall – 23:29
Yeah, that one’s a tough one because, like you said, at least it’s come to the point where there’s not huge differences. That’s the kind of thing you dig into and you hear, “Well, this department’s not giving it up because it does this weird one little thing,” and the other department won’t either. Usually with all this kind of stuff, it gets into a pattern where there’s kind of an upfront fee if you go with them as a vendor, but it’s usually very cost-effective just to add more capacity—to buy more tokens or whatever—as opposed to leaving three running at the same time. That’s pretty much worst-case scenario.
Katie Robbert – 23:58
Of course, everything in my office is freaking out because I’m saying brand names. They think that I’m trying to trigger them awake, and I’m wondering what is happening. Next you have content and media: Adobe Creative Cloud, Descript, Riverside, Loom, Grammarly, and Canva Pro. Again, I think it’s a matter of taking a look at why you’re using them. A lot of times we just end up using things that are convenient, and it becomes a legacy and just hangs around. For example, I like to use Hemingway Editor. It’s just a tool that I really like. It’s a word processing tool; it helps me edit. Do I need it? Probably not. Am I paying for it? Yes. Those are the kinds of decisions that internally we need to make.
Katie Robbert – 24:49
We’re also paying for Adobe Creative Cloud. At one point we were paying for SignRequest, which is how you send things out for signatures. Now we do it through Adobe Creative Cloud. Because we’re a Google Workspace shop, there’s actually some feature in Google Workspace that also allows you to do it. It’s one of these things where we have to really take a critical eye to say, “Have the features become available in the tools we’re paying for?” Which means we can then drop Adobe Creative Cloud, for example.
John Wall – 25:27
Yeah, Adobe is like its own whole category of headache and ridiculousness. It’s insane because I pay a flat monthly rate, yet there’s still all kinds of weird add-ons and additional things. Like you said, the whole landscape of PDF is crazy. There’s the one you get with the suite, but there’s also a dedicated one that can do more things. Now there’s more stuff baked into the browser, though a lot of that stuff is handcuffed and can’t do a lot of the same stuff. There’s kind of no way to do that but to again dig in and do the hard work of asking, “Okay, what exactly does this do and what exactly are we paying for?” Get to a point where you can figure out what’s going on.
Katie Robbert – 26:12
Then we have our favorite category: other. In this synthetic example, we have Dropbox, we have SQ Digital SVC—nobody knows what that is—and four $1 charges with no clear vendor, which is something that we’d probably flag back over to our accounting team and say, “Hey, can you help us figure this out?” When I look at this, I say, “Well, we have Dropbox here, but I thought we were also using Google Workspace for $2,500, which includes Drive. So why do we need both?”
John Wall – 26:47
Yeah, that’s a great question. Dropbox has had a bunch of legacy products, so that could be some other thing. Just because it says Dropbox doesn’t mean it’s the first file-sharing thing. Or, like you said, it’s just forgotten. In some orgs you do want to have that in case for some reason Google Drive tanks this week. You can’t have the sales staff not be able to get to all the marketing materials and the sales materials just because some vendor decided to hiccup. The SQ one made me laugh. For any small business people that have done this, yeah, that’s Square. That shows up and comes into mine—I don’t even need QuickBooks, I just use Quicken.
John Wall – 27:27
It does have baked in as part of your upload: “If you see SQ, correct it to Square and put it in this category.” I’m sure QuickBooks must have the same level of stuff, and you can build around that. That’s just a whole other headache. There’s nothing worse than when you run the report and you find these 50 mystery charges and you have no idea where the heck they come from.
Katie Robbert – 27:50
That is my least favorite part of all of this because that is something that I have to do on a regular basis. This is the first part of the prompt. To recap: in this week’s Inbox Insights, Chris gave you the structure for a prompt to do this analysis. Here’s the prompt, here’s what the audit found, here’s what you’re paying for, and then the prompt through your LLM will give you some starting points to take a look at. Here are some clear cuts based on the information that you gave AI to say, “This is what we’re doing.” Google One AI Premium: Google Workspace business plans include the Gemini app. We’re actually paying for Gemini twice, which is sneaky because neither one says, “This is where Gemini lives.”
Katie Robbert – 28:39
You have to do that digging. We talked about Dropbox—Google Workspace includes Drive storage. The one caveat that I would give here is depending on what kind of industry you work in, Dropbox or Drive may not be secure enough to send files. You may actually need a separate file-sharing service in order to pass information or data that includes PII or something like that. I remember when I worked in a more regulated field, that was something that we had. We had to have a separate FTP way to upload files that were secure. There was a password, and I don’t know that Drive meets that criteria—I haven’t looked into it. It’s something to consider as you ask, “Well, why am I paying for this?”
Katie Robbert – 29:31
This gives you the opportunity to do something like—oh, I don’t know—the 5P Framework by Trust Insights to walk through: What is the purpose of it? Who are the people who use it? What is the process for when this piece of software is getting used? What is the platform, and does it touch other software? And what is the performance outcome—did it answer the question being asked? When you’re talking about file storage and file sharing, if your purpose is to securely share files outside of your organization, or to store files inside your organization that contain sensitive information, it may be why you’re paying for additional file sharing and storage. Those are the questions you have to pause and ask before just saying, “Okay, let me just add something else,” or “Let me just drop something.”
John Wall – 30:22
Another thing with this too that I got to point out is AI is just fantastic for this, because for the clear cuts it can suggest to you, “Hey, if you jump up to the professional level, you’re already paying that much because you have 35 users, and you’ll unlock more data, more features, whatever.” It’s one thing to look at all the expenses and figure out what we don’t need and what we can cut, but really only AI is going to be able to do all the legwork of, “Okay, here’s all your existing plans. What if you jumped up to a new one?” These plans change all the time. There’s probably new plans since you originally signed four years ago.
John Wall – 31:01
The software companies are clearly aware of this. They know that you could be on a better plan and getting more stuff for less money, but they’re not going to cut their own profitability. They’re going to wait for you to find that on your own, and most customers don’t find it on their own. Running it through a prompt like this can be huge. You can identify amazing opportunities to basically get a lot more power, or even in worst-case scenarios, you’re working with a company that’s so evil that you’re paying for 35 seats and if you just bought the 30-plus license pack, you’d be paying less for the exact same thing. That does happen too.
Katie Robbert – 31:37
It’s funny you bring that up because when I looked at our expenses—and Adobe Creative Cloud is one of them—we’re not taking advantage of the bundled users. We’re all paying for individual plans which cost more, versus bundling it for me, you, Chris, and Kelsey to each have a seat in one license or something like that. That’s something we’re absolutely not taking advantage of. One of the things that you can also use generative AI to do is that deep research: “Hey, I’m paying for Google Workspace. What does it do? What are the features that I’m not using?” That’s a separate prompt—a deep research project.
Katie Robbert – 32:24
You can then take that deep research, compare it to this analysis, and you may find there’s even more opportunity to cut different software that you’re paying for because there’s just features that you aren’t currently using that you already have access to. Next, if we keep going: Dropbox we talked about. Jasper was flagged—no one has logged in since March. ChatGPT and Claude cover the same writing work. That’s a big overlap of things that you’re paying for that you probably just forgot that you had, or maybe the person who signed up for it is gone and nobody knew that you were still paying for this thing. Squarespace hosts a 2024 event microsite that nobody links to.
John Wall – 33:13
That happens to the best of us.
Katie Robbert – 33:13
That happens to the best of us.
John Wall – 33:15
Programs expire. And now, if you’re at a certain company and you just laid off a quarter of your workforce, all those people were signing up for stuff and using tools. Unless you go back and figure out who originally signed off on stuff, this stuff just stays around forever.
Katie Robbert – 33:36
Monday.com: a second project management tool next to Asana. Again, these are things that look easy on paper to make cuts on, but there is actually change management that has to happen within your organization. As I mentioned, I like to use Hemingway Editor. I could be editing within an AI assistant or just using Google Docs, but I like to have the extra grammar assistant that I get with Hemingway Editor and not use a straight AI tool like Claude. That would be change management for me—I would then have to decide what other tool is comparable to what I’m using where I’m going to get the same kind of quality of output. With Monday.com and Asana, project management tools are really tough to get people using them and using them well.
Katie Robbert – 34:29
At Trust Insights, we’ve actually run the gamut of pretty much every project management tool to try to find the version of a tool that people on our team would use consistently. It could be that this team has been using Monday forever and this team has been using Asana forever, and the work is getting done and getting done well. It’s worth keeping both tools versus trying to migrate. The cost of trying to migrate people over and then also getting them to build those new habits—those are other considerations.
John Wall – 35:01
Yeah, switching costs are real. “Okay, you’re going to save $50 a month, and it’s going to cost us $10,000 to make that change this year.” Well, we’re never getting that money back. Then it’s also the spiderweb of, “Okay, well, Asana is plugged into Slack, email, and our calendar. So if you rip and replace that, can the new tool do that stuff?” Again, that’s just going to be more hours of rip-and-replace that you may never get a return on, so maybe it’s not worth chasing.
Katie Robbert – 35:31
Then overlaps to check: Zoom versus Google Meet. Again, if you are paying for Google Workspace, do you also need to be paying for Zoom? This prompt is giving us that check: “Check first—do clients require Zoom?” We are a Google Workspace shop, and we’ve had clients who’ve struggled to get into Google Meet, so we’ve had to then switch into their Zoom. It doesn’t make it as seamless as possible. Much like your file sharing, what are the requirements of your clients? Is Zoom more user-friendly? Is it more regulatory compliant? Whatever the situation is that requires you to have more than one system for something. Same with Mailchimp: you have Mailchimp and HubSpot marketing email—two email platforms.
Katie Robbert – 36:24
We have two email platforms, but we don’t use one of them. We have our CRM that has an email platform built into it, though we’re not paying for that. We actually have a different marketing automation system that we maintain ourselves, so we have to pay for the server, not the software. It’s just a matter of working styles. Would I love for our marketing automation system to be more intuitive and user-friendly? Yes, but then the cost of what we’re paying for is going to go up. You pay for that ease of use.
John Wall – 36:58
Yeah, it’s just crazy because we’re in a weird situation in that we have far more contacts than the average business our size. We’re having to worry about mailing millions of pieces over a quarter, so we have to do a little extra gymnastics to make that work.
Katie Robbert – 37:15
Then we have Descript versus Riverside—both record and edit the podcast. Which one does the producer actually use? This happens a lot where you think, “I’ve been using this tool forever. Let me just see what this one also does.” Then you just forget about it and end up paying. Do you do a lot of editing, John? Do you have multiple editing tools, or do you just have one tool that does it all?
John Wall – 37:38
I was talking to the folks at Riverside actually—they reached out to me recently, so I started digging into all this stuff, and it’s interesting. On paper those two look the same, except now you’ve got Riverside, and then SquadCast is in the mix too. All three of those are pretty much the same in that they’re designed for top-quality recording and then doing stuff downstream. If you saw that and you saw StreamYard that we’re using right now, 90% of StreamYard is the same. However, the core focus of StreamYard is that we’re pushing this to LinkedIn, YouTube, and Twitch all at the same time. That streaming is the number one priority for StreamYard.
John Wall – 38:24
Even though you’ve got multiple tools, the use cases do affect it. They’re in the same category, but depending on what you want to do with it, it’s a little different thing. The end result of that one is I am taking Riverside for a spin in the next couple of weeks. Again, it’s the same deal: you want to be good at streaming, but Riverside’s new features are supposedly great as far as doing video clips and having AI just create those clips and have them spit out the other end without any labor. StreamYard doesn’t have that functionality, so there’s a lot going on in this space here.
Katie Robbert – 39:00
Again, it’s like a throwback to the 5Ps. As you’re talking through it, John, it occurs to me you have very specific needs, and if you walked each part of your process through the 5P Framework, you could say, “Does Riverside meet this? Does StreamYard meet this? Does this other tool meet this?” for what I’m trying to do. That’s the homework for everybody watching this. As you get this analysis—because the analysis is the easy part, putting this together is the easy part—what you do about it is the hard part. Next, you have renewing in the next 45 days. It gives you that timeline of how quickly we need to make a decision, which is also helpful.
Katie Robbert – 39:47
There’s two clear cuts on here, Dropbox and Squarespace, that would save us roughly just under $600—about $550. Every one of these renews on its own if nobody acts, so that’s also good to know. Then what the data itself shows: one vendor, three names—Google charges under Google Workspace, Google G Suite, and Google Cloud. Seven tools could not be matched to a person who uses them, so that’s a big red flag. Small charges add up: 22 domain renewals averaging about $30 each. If we don’t make decisions on whether we want to own those domains, that’s another $640. And then about $123 worth of unknown charges that nobody recognizes. That doesn’t seem like a lot, but it adds up, especially when you’re counting every penny.
John Wall – 40:45
Yeah, and the thing with those is asking, “What the heck is that? Is that a tool that’s not being used, or are these some kind of finance charges that can get rolled into something else?” I did have one other thing too: for the ones with no owners whatsoever, we use the scream test for that. You just shut that thing off and see who yells.
Katie Robbert – 41:08
That is fantastic. I like that. It’s a good way to see who’s using it. Sending out a company-wide email asking, “Hey, who’s using this and this?” is easy to ignore. You can make it more actionable by actually cutting off access, and then someone says, “Hey, I suddenly can’t get all of my daily work done.” Then you say, “Oh, okay, that’s helpful to know.”
John Wall – 41:29
Right, and there is a level of risk with that. Maybe review the CEO’s tool list before you start just pulling plugs on things, because you don’t want to break something that is way more important than you thought it was.
Katie Robbert – 41:44
Then one overlooked feature. Again, this is all from that one prompt putting in your information, and from the follow-up prompt—there’s two prompts in the newsletter. The feature is “Take notes for me,” where Gemini writes notes during a Google Meet. It’s meeting transcription. We are also using some other tool to do the meeting transcription. Again, it’s the overlooked features: if you’re paying for Google Workspace, you can replace Calendly and you can replace your meeting transcriptions. To your point, John, make sure that if you shut off Calendly, you see who’s going to scream about it and whether they know that there’s other options. This gives you information on how to start looking at those overlooked features, and then the prompt gives you next steps.
Katie Robbert – 42:39
Cancel the six clear cuts, starting with the two that renew first. Get one answer for each overlap to check—so you have to talk to people. Name an owner for every tool on the list—this is your scream test. Then set one rule for new tools: a named owner and renewal date before that first charge. You can set up a calendar reminder or a task reminder—something that tells you, “Hey, before it gets charged another $2,000 for the year, this thing is going to renew.” This is the analysis that you can do from the prompt in Inbox Insights. Again, you can go to TrustInsights.ai/newsletter, subscribe to the newsletter, and you can actually get that prompt in your inbox. What did we miss? What did we forget to do?
John Wall – 43:28
That’s really it. Like I said, dig in there and see what you can find. There’s always stuff in there that can be cleaned up, and stuff that’s broken and forgotten about. It even goes further than just software. Pretty much everything in your org has this happen. There’s all kinds of subscriptions to trade associations and people subscribing to different types of services—not just software, but the people bringing the coffee to the office and the spring water and all these things. Generative AI tools are really good at this stuff because they chew up all the data. They can compare it to what they expect it to be, and they have a full understanding of what they should be based on the rest of the universe.
John Wall – 44:12
The human mind just can’t do that kind of stuff. This is a prime use case for running these prompts.
Katie Robbert – 44:19
The way that I was operating before I thought was effective, but I was missing a lot. I would take a look at the Amex statement month over month as it came out, look at each individual charge, and ask about it—”What is this? What is this?” It didn’t give me that full picture of, “You’re paying for this and you’re paying for this,” because I was looking at it with the human brain, to your point, John. It’s a lot of information. Let the AI tool synthesize all of that information together so that you can make decisions. That’s the hard part. As we’re talking about taming the MarTech sprawl, let the AI tool do the easy part, which is analyzing all of the data to give you that report.
Katie Robbert – 45:00
Then you have to make a decision: Who’s going to use this thing? Can we use the 5P Framework by Trust Insights to figure out why the heck we’re paying for this thing in the first place? Again, the five Ps: purpose—why do we need this? People—who needs access to it, and does everybody need their own individual license to it? Process—what does it do? Platform—does it need other tools to be able to work, that integration? And performance—did it solve the problem it was set out to solve? That’s our recommendation on how you tame your MarTech sprawl. I also recommend you do this exercise at least once a quarter, not just annually.
Katie Robbert – 45:44
If you only do it annually—and I apparently have a Muppet or something behind me, I don’t know what she’s doing—you’re going to miss a lot of things. You may have missed those renewal windows, and you may be paying for something that you meant to cancel the month before.
John Wall – 46:02
Yeah, that’s the other huge win of having AI say, “Okay, and oh, by the way, these are the three that renew in the next three months.” If you don’t hit them at the renewal points, they’re all set up with cancellation fees so that they’re going to steal the rest of the money for the year from you, whether you use it or not—or it just won’t shut off. They’re just going to say, “Hey, you’re paid, so you’ll switch next November.” Having the system be able to watch that for you too is great. And the other one is: don’t worry about the two-thirds of them where you’ve still got nine months to go. It’s just not the time to even dig into those.
Katie Robbert – 46:39
All right, any final thoughts?
John Wall – 46:42
Good luck digging. It’s the end of the year. This is where you find your bonus. This is where the Christmas party comes from.
Katie Robbert – 46:47

That’s right. All right, if you want to join the conversation, you can join our free Slack community at TrustInsights.ai/analyticsformarketers. We covered MarTech sprawl on the podcast earlier this week to introduce it; you can get that at TrustInsights.ai/tipodcast. This livestream and other episodes of the livestream are on our YouTube channel, its So What? playlist, at TrustInsights.ai/youtube. As always, if you want help with any of this, you can contact Mr. John Wall here at TrustInsights.ai/contact. No livestream next week, as next Thursday is Thanksgiving in the United States, so we will be taking a break for a couple of days and we will return the following week. See you then.


Need help with your marketing AI and analytics?

You might also enjoy:

Get unique data, analysis, and perspectives on analytics, insights, machine learning, marketing, and AI in the weekly Trust Insights newsletter, INBOX INSIGHTS. Subscribe now for free; new issues every Wednesday!

Click here to subscribe now »

Want to learn more about data, analytics, and insights? Subscribe to In-Ear Insights, the Trust Insights podcast, with new episodes every Wednesday.


Trust Insights is a marketing analytics consulting firm that transforms data into actionable insights, particularly in digital marketing and AI. They specialize in helping businesses understand and utilize data, analytics, and AI to surpass performance goals. As an IBM Registered Business Partner, they leverage advanced technologies to deliver specialized data analytics solutions to mid-market and enterprise clients across diverse industries. Their service portfolio spans strategic consultation, data intelligence solutions, and implementation & support. Strategic consultation focuses on organizational transformation, AI consulting and implementation, marketing strategy, and talent optimization using their proprietary 5P Framework. Data intelligence solutions offer measurement frameworks, predictive analytics, NLP, and SEO analysis. Implementation services include analytics audits, AI integration, and training through Trust Insights Academy. Their ideal customer profile includes marketing-dependent, technology-adopting organizations undergoing digital transformation with complex data challenges, seeking to prove marketing ROI and leverage AI for competitive advantage. Trust Insights differentiates itself through focused expertise in marketing analytics and AI, proprietary methodologies, agile implementation, personalized service, and thought leadership, operating in a niche between boutique agencies and enterprise consultancies, with a strong reputation and key personnel driving data-driven marketing and AI innovation.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This